Commuter Benefit Laws by City and State

Last updated: November 4, 2026.

Ten cities, states and regions require employers to offer pretax commuter benefits. Fines reach $300 a day in Philadelphia and up to $5,000 a day in the Bay Area. Who must offer it, which employees count, recordkeeping and fines vary by place, but the core benefit is the same: a pretax payroll election under the federal commuter benefit rule (§132(f)), up to the IRS monthly limit ($340 per month for transit and $340 per month for qualified parking in 2026).

Alice helps employers offer and document the benefit in each location they operate. The employer remains the entity responsible for compliance; Alice supplies the pretax payroll mechanism, employee enrollment flow, eligibility documentation, and Alice Card (a Visa commercial credit card) when available under the plan.

Commuter benefits by location

  • New York City: Local Law 53: covers for-profit and nonprofit employers with 20 or more full-time non-union employees working in NYC. Transit only. Written offer and two years of records. NYC DCWP enforces; fines of $100 to $250 for a first violation not fixed within 90 days, then $250 for every 30 days you stay out of compliance.
  • New Jersey: statewide commuter benefits law: employers with 20 or more employees in New Jersey. Limited union-contract exclusion. NJDOL enforces; fines of $100 to $250 for a first violation not fixed within 90 days, then $250 for every 30 days you stay out of compliance.
  • San Francisco & Bay Area: SF Commuter Benefits Ordinance (20+ employees anywhere, with employees working 10+ hours a week in SF; fines up to $100, $200 and $500 within a year) plus the Bay Area Commuter Benefits Program (50+ full-time employees in the nine-county Bay Area Air District; fines up to $5,000 a day). SF Environment and the Bay Area Air District enforce them.

Other places that require commuter benefits

  • Washington, DC: employers with 20 or more employees who do at least half their work in DC. Fines of $100 to $800 per employee a month.
  • Seattle: employers with 20 or more employees anywhere, for employees working 10+ hours a week in Seattle. First violations bring fines up to $500.
  • Chicago area (Illinois): employers with 50 or more employees at a Chicago-area location within a mile of transit. The law sets no fine amount.
  • Philadelphia: employers with 50 or more employees averaging 30 hours a week in the city. Fines of $150 to $300 a day after a written warning.
  • Berkeley, CA: employers with 10 or more employees. No city fine, but employees can sue.
  • Richmond, CA: businesses with 10 or more employees averaging 10+ hours a week. The city publishes no fine amount.

For all ten places in one table, see our 2026 guide to commuter benefit laws.

What commuter benefit laws usually require

Most commuter benefit laws share three elements:

  • An offer. Covered employers must offer eligible employees the opportunity to use pretax income for qualified commuter expenses, up to the federal IRS monthly limit.
  • Documentation. Employers must maintain records showing the offer was made and that eligible employees had the opportunity to elect.
  • Fines. Usually after a warning or a period to fix the problem, and they grow the longer you stay out of compliance.

Headcounts and fines differ by place. Check the page for your location above for the exact rules.

How Alice supports compliance

Alice connects to your existing payroll system and supports the offer workflow, employee enrollment flow, eligibility documentation, the pretax payroll deduction, and Alice Card (a Visa commercial credit card) for eligible spending. Setup typically takes about one week from order form to first payroll run.

Alice’s employer pricing is designed so employer fees do not exceed employer payroll tax savings from the program (exact pricing depends on the employer agreement and program terms).

Contact sales@thisisalice.com or (929) 552-4625. Setup starts with one call.

Alice does not provide tax, legal, or financial advice. Consult qualified counsel for guidance specific to your business.